The ripple effect of innovation in education
ANNUAL REPORT 2023
EXECUTIVE LETTER
The National Science Foundation says that American businesses spent $602 billion in research and development in 2021 to develop new products and competitive advantages.
Innovation is just as important in the field of education, yet with tight budgets and limited resources, schools and community organizations don’t often have the luxury of an R&D budget. But that doesn’t mean those educators and leaders don’t develop creative new ways to help young people and change lives.
At Greater Texas Foundation, we walk alongside those changemakers. And we strive to be their partner in creating innovations that can be shared, scaled, and sustained to benefit students across the state. That’s why our strategic plan includes a goal to specifically support innovative projects as part of the foundation’s grantmaking strategy. But you can also find strong examples of innovative work across our entire portfolio of partners and projects. We commit to being both a funder and a collaborator that gives our partners the resources to create bold, impactful change for Texas students.
Over the course of our strategic plan, we have supported a host of strong, innovative projects. In this report, we share the work of two grantees who have nurtured powerful ideas into effective solutions that benefit many Texas students and youth. We’re proud to provide the support that helps our grantees take smart risks and grow their impact.
Philanthropy is often said to be America’s greatest risk capital, and I believe that GTF and other funders like us allow for nonprofits and schools to take chances on things to try. Things may work, or may not work, but it allows for the ability to take those chances and then scale the programs that work really well.
Sue McMillin, President and CEO
Ripples of Impact Across Texas
Our definition of innovation:
Nurturing a Culture of Learning
Learning from trial and error is an essential part of the innovation process that can generate new ideas and lead to breakthroughs. With this in mind, we foster a culture that encourages grantees to report failures and lessons learned. Maintaining strong and open channels of communication ensures grantees feel comfortable reporting both successes and failures.
E3 Alliance - Math means momentum
E3 Alliance’s commitment to systems change is grounded in data and analysis. And a decade ago the data told a clear story of how to help more Texas students succeed in school by strengthening math education. The passage of HB 5 legislation in 2013 drastically lowered the requirements for student course-taking in math, and many district, higher ed, and foundation leaders were very concerned about the implications of this policy change, so GTF funded E3 Alliance to do ground-breaking research on the connection between math course completion and later education outcomes. Informed by this data, Greater Texas Foundation began funding E3 Alliance’s Pathways of Promise work in Central Texas in 2014.
The data revealed the opportunity
- Students who take advanced math in middle and high school significantly increase their post-high school success and wages in the workforce.
- Students taking math all four years in high school double their likelihood of attaining a postsecondary credential.
- Students who enroll in a college-aligned course in high school are six times more likely to complete a postsecondary credential.
Texas students begin their advanced math journey in middle school based on 5th grade outcomes. Research found that enrolling in advanced math in middle school is not often based on any objective measure of demonstrated math aptitude. The missed opportunity was particularly pronounced among historically underserved populations. Of all 5th-grade 2014 STAAR test math takers in Texas, fewer than 33% of Black and 46% of Hispanic students with scores in the top 20% completed Algebra I by 8th grade.
The districts proved the case
One example of a limiting factor was the practice of having middle school students opt into Algebra I. As a result, too few students took this critically-important course. So, participating districts set shared goals for enhancing equitable outcomes for students across their campuses and they saw marked change for the entire region.
For example, Hays CISD reversed tactics in 2020. Rather than opting into advanced math, they automatically enrolled qualifying students, creating an opt-out policy.
“Since making this shift, our enrollment in middle school advanced mathematics courses and 8th-grade Algebra grew by 29%, allowing over 200 additional students to thrive with a more appropriate, rigorous, and challenging curriculum,” explained Derek McDaniel, Director of Curriculum and Instruction, Hays CISD
About the Partner
A long-term partnership
10 years | 7 grants | $2.6M
Districts across Central Texas collectively adopted this opt-out policy and the results were striking. The policy significantly increased the rate of Algebra I completion across the board and significantly decreased equity gaps for low-income students and students of color. These changes to regional practices decreased the gap between high-performing Black and White students being enrolled into advanced middle school math pathways by 91%!
Hear how three Central Texas school districts embraced math for all
Systems change ensured sustainable impact
– Sue McMillin
Aspen Institute: Sourcing Sustainable Funding
In 2018, an estimated 462,300 Texans aged 16-24 were not in school and not working. They are known as opportunity youth. Beyond the lost human potential of such disconnection, the state loses $20,000-40,000 per year with each opportunity youth, according to Dr. Hannah Gourgey, Senior Fellow at the Aspen Institute’s Opportunity Youth Forum. Many communities across the state often have strong programming to aid opportunity youth, largely serving small numbers through private philanthropy. But these communities can benefit from learning ways to scale their programs and find sustainable funding.
A 2021 research report by Jobs for the Future (JFF) began to point the way for communities to source public funding and leverage Texas policies that support pathways for opportunity youth to attain high school and postsecondary credentials. (See related box below.)
Connecting communities to sustainable resources
With seed funding from Greater Texas Foundation, Texas Opportunity Youth Network (TOYN) launched an Innovation Fund to support existing regional opportunity youth collaboratives. The Aspen Opportunity Youth Forum is leading the effort to increase community and program expertise, leverage state policy and public/private funding partnerships, and build sustainable and scalable opportunity youth pathways statewide.
Since GTF’s initial seed funding, the community of partner funders has grown – more than doubling the original $1 million investment. This funding covers planning, piloting a revenue model, and launch.
The Innovation Fund was born from this initial question: “How much money are we leaving on the table that could help us serve opportunity youth?” The Fund now has three goals:
- Build the capacity to draw down public funding and leverage existing policies to expand and sustain their opportunity youth programs.
- Receive coaching to overcome regulatory or precedent barriers to getting these funds.
- Form a community of practice that shares learning.
About the Partner
The Aspen Institute has earned a reputation for gathering diverse, nonpartisan thought leaders, creatives, scholars and members of the public to address some of the world’s most complex problems. But the goal of these convenings is to have an impact beyond the conference room. They are designed to provoke, further and improve actions taken in the real world. Education is one of their nine areas of strategic focus.
Our investment: $1M
With more than $2 million pooled from 5 funders, the Aspen Institute awarded 11 planning grants to community organizations serving as regional backbones. Organizations that received funds for planning work emerged well-positioned and strategically prepared to pilot new initiatives. Eight communities have now received funding for pilot programs. Here are two examples of teams that have creatively sourced resources for their programs:
Corpus Christi
Waco
Prosper Waco and Heart of Texas Behavioral Health Network are building a new community-wide approach to serving opportunity youth. They have secured funding from Medicaid and the Workforce Innovation & Opportunity Act (WIOA) Program to help them serve youth with disabilities and behavioral health issues.
Big picture benefits
What is the benefit of this work? “The State of Texas will gain $26 billion by re-engaging its opportunity youth,” says Dr. Hannah Gourgey of the Aspen Institute. That includes restoring lost wage income, savings in health and social services, and avoidance of justice system involvement. And that is a powerful wave of change.
Convening Report:
Funding opportunities for opportunity youth
From the JFF report, here are examples of how schools and organizations can access funding that will benefit disconnected youth:
- Texas is unique in that, through House Bill 1137, it allocates per-pupil funding based on average daily attendance for school districts to re-engage young people up to age 25 who left high school without graduating so they can earn a diploma. School districts can draw down this average daily attendance funding to support opportunity youth.
- Independent school districts (ISDs) can apply for District of Innovation status, and have charter school-like flexibility in their curricula, instruction, budgets, and governance, among other measures; this status could be leveraged for schools serving opportunity youth.
- Among the provisions passed in House Bill 3 are college, career, and military readiness bonuses for school districts that prepare students for those paths.
- Texas Workforce Commission (TWC) administers federal funding for adult education and literacy (AEL). Through a competitive process, TWC awards multi-year grants to eligible AEL providers.
GTF Scholars Are The Future
Natalia Murguia
The University of Texas at El Paso (UTEP)
Majoring in English with a Minor in Education
Graduating Spring 2025
Attended Montwood High School in El Paso
Why is a college education important to you?
My parents instilled the importance of education in me at a young age. My mom didn’t go to college and my dad began college after they learned they were having me. I attended his graduation from UTEP when I was seven years old and eleven years later he watched me earn my associates degree. I saw that a college degree made it easier for my dad to get a higher paying job. My mom has to work harder for less money.
Can you share some successes you’ve had in college so far
I’m really proud of having a 4.0 GPA and having no debt. In addition to being a GTF Scholar, I was awarded an Academic Excellence Scholarship from UTEP, a Stars Scholarship, the El Paso McDonald’s Scholarship, and the Senior Airman Danny Ray Sanchez Foundation Scholarship. It is a huge relief to only focus on school. It would be so hard to focus if I had to work to afford school.
What are some challenges you’ve faced in navigating the transition to college?
Early College High School prepared me for the workload, the lecture style, and using Blackboard. But it was a challenge to move to an independent learning environment and I had to learn to manage my time between academics and social life. The GTF Scholars office helped make it a smoother transition.
How has being a GTF Scholar impacted your college experience?
I definitely feel the support from the GTF Scholars.Their intent is behind their words. Initially, I had a hard time dealing with the college’s Financial Aid Office, but the GTF program coordinator helped me settle my issues.
They have hosted lots of amazing workshops. In a LInkedIn workshop we learned to write our bios and follow things that interest us. And they took professional headshots of us in work attire. There were also workshops on resume building and a fun one about personality types (StrengthsFinder) And a workshop with Student Affairs introduced us to resources on campus like IT, the writing center, academic advising, and I learned how to navigate the Education program application.
What do you plan to do after you finish your degree?
I am currently student-teaching at Young Women’s STEAM Research & Preparatory Academy and I’d love to teach there after graduation. Instruction there is so different from other schools–they interrupt each other productively, help each other–it’s a collaborative place. I want to teach there while getting a master’s degree in library science. I love El Paso but am open to going elsewhere.
Tell us about an influential figure in your life.
In my junior year of high school I took English Composition from Mr. Hemling. He also sponsored the literary anthology club and was coach for the High Q club. I saw how “unapologetically himself” he was. The way he organized all those activities made me want to do that in life!
What do you do to relax and have fun?
For as long as I can remember I’ve had my head in a book. I also play the cello. It helps me relax and convey my feelings. The tone of the cello is as close to the human voice as an instrument can get. I also play volleyball and enjoy mountain biking. (As if we need proof, she points to a bandage on her chin from a recent ride.)
What book are you recommending right now?
My favorite book now is The Count of Monte Cristo. It’s resonating right now for me as the main character is constantly changing his identity.
Alan Ramirez Treja
University of Houston – Downtown
Majoring in Chemistry
Graduating Spring 2025
Attended Attended Alief Early College High School
Why is a college education important to you?
I want a college degree for myself and for my parents. They want a different life for me than they had. I really enjoy school. I like to take on challenges and try my best in everything. The moment I took chemistry in high school it really made me realize I loved that field and wanted to major in it. I earned my associates degree in science through my Early College High School.
What do you plan to do after you finish your degree?
For a long time, I wanted to be in the field of medicine but patient contact and surgery is not for me. In pharmacy, I can help without having to see blood! I plan to attend pharmacy school after college and maybe get a doctorate.
What has been your favorite course or activity in college?
I loved my service learning project in organic chemistry. Over a semester we had to do research, conduct surveys, create essays and posters, and make a presentation to convince local high school students not to take drugs. Our team worked on fentanyl and I learned how easily the drug can be accessed. When the students came to our campus for the presentation, we talked about groups and organizations that could help them with avoidance, support, or treatment.
What are some challenges you’ve faced in navigating the transition to college? How did you get help?
At the start, I was confident I knew how it was going to go. I didn’t realize that in high school I had free periods to study but in college I have to make time to study within my full schedule. I learned from a GTF Scholars workshop to make an agenda for the day and create my to-do list (not just a sticky note).
How else has being a GTF Scholar impacted your college experience?
We have a GTF Scholars lounge and it’s useful to have a study room close by. People are quiet there and I can pop in between classes. Our campus coordinator is Thalina Sabido and she is great for any questions I have or to share opinions or contacts.
Another workshop on using LinkedIn was helpful. We learned how to present ourselves, how to apply for internships, what makes a good, credible internship, etc. I would like an internship in a pharmacy or hospital.
What do you do to relax and have fun?
I play video games, watch series, and read mangas. I also enjoy dancing. I was in a folkloric group in middle school and we won awards. Mostly I dance to popular music now.
What’s next for you?
I will attempt to earn a pharmacy certification this summer to make sure I really like the field. I plan to work at a local pharmacy. After 500 hours of work, I can apply to take the certification test.
More Scholar Stories
Hear other GTF Scholars reflect on their progress from ECHS to college in this video.
Grant Activity
Grants Approved in 2023
Student Supports
To support the Latino Student Success (LSS) Funders Group which brings together funders interested in supporting the success of Latino students. Participation in this network allows GTF to stay up to date with current trends and topics in the field. (Excelencia in Education, Inc.)
To support a comprehensive, multi-year strategy to increase data-informed reporting and coverage of higher education issues in Texas. This will include a redesign of the Tribune’s Schools Explorer database to improve functionality for Texans looking for critical statewide education data and information. (Texas Tribune, Inc.)
To support E3 Alliance’s Blueprint Summit on September 13, 2023, where E3 Alliance will release the Blueprint for Educational Change, which outlines Central Texas’ strategic plan to build a strong, equitable education-to-workforce pipeline. (E3 Alliance)
To support the personal growth and academic achievement of people impacted by the justice system through participation in Pathways from Prison to Postsecondary Education. (Lee College Foundation, Inc.)
2023 Membership ($3,700)
To support the foundation’s 2023 membership to Grantmakers for Education. (Grantmakers for Education)
- Baylor University
- Howard Payne University
- Southwestern University (2)
- Stephen F. Austin State University (2)
- Texas A&M Foundation (2)
- Texas State University Development Foundation
- The Texas A&M University Commerce Foundation (2)
- Tyler Junior College Foundation
Dr. John Moss – Honorary Endowed Scholarship ($100,000)
To contribute to the John & Peggy Moss Endowed Scholarship which supports education majors with a concentration in mathematics at Texas A&M University-Texarkana.
Vision
- Ralph Rushing, Chair
- Dr. Samuel Gillespie, Vice Chair, Finance & Investment Committee Chair
- Bill Youngkin, Secretary, Audit & Accountability Committee Chair
- Dr. John Moss, Charitable Activities Committee Co-Chair
- Dr. Alonzo Sosa, Charitable Activities Committee Co-Chair
- Dr. Donald Thompson, Strategy & Learning Committee Chair
- Judy Holt, Director
- A.D. James, Jr., Director
- Dr. Terry Jones, Director
- Tina Gridiron, Advisor to the Strategy & Learning Committee
- Janet Handley, Advisor to the Finance & Investment Committee
- Dr. Mary Hendrix, Advisor to the Charitable Activities Committee
- Jodi Jones, Advisor to the Audit & Accountability Committee
- Sue McMillin, President & CEO
- Nancy Mader, Office Manager
- Erin Arnold, Senior Accountant
- Amber Bass, Chief Financial Officer
- Leslie Gurrola, Director of Programs & Strategy
- Carol Miller, Director of Grants Management
- Tessa Pennington, Programs & Strategy Associate
- Dr. Andrea Robledo, Programs & Strategy Officer
- Chris Woodruff, Senior Grants Management Associate
- Emma Reed, Graduate Intern
- Rylie Bridgford
- Kaci Herman
- Alexandria Christian
- Jen Jernigan
- Paige Hubert